ALL GOVERNMENTS LIE, THE MOVIE

November 6, 2016 – 5:03 am

JUST TO LET YOU KNOW
To reduce spamming, the BigO website is going through Cloudflare. What it does is scan your browser to ensure the visitor is not a spam. Do not be alarmed as this usually takes only a few seconds. Email us if you still have difficulty accessing the BigO site; or playing or downloading the tracks. If you know a better way of reducing spam, do let us know.

+ + + + +


All governments lie and they are ably assisted by the mainstream press in their respective countries. For without the press, how could the lies spread throughout the land? By David Swanson.

Picture, if you will, video footage of vintage (early 2016) Donald Trump buffoonery with the CEO of CBS Leslie Moonves commenting on major media’s choice to give Trump vastly more air time than other candidates: “It may not be good for America, but it’s damn good for CBS.”

That’s the introduction to a powerful critique of the US media. A new film screens in New York and Los Angeles this week called All Governments Lie: Truth, Deception, And The Spirit Of IF Stone (click here).

The website AllGovernmentsLie.com has screening dates, a list of lies, and a list of good journalists who expose lies. The lists on the website are not identical to the content of the film, but there’s a good deal of overlap - enough to give you a sense of what this project is about.

I’d have made various changes and additions to the film. In particular, I’m tired of all the focus on Iraq 2003. This film touches on war lies since then, but still gives that one particular set of war lies prominence.

Still, this is a film that should be shown in cities, homes, and classrooms across the United States. It includes and is driven by Noam Chomsky’s analysis of how the media system is “rigged” without those doing the rigging believing they’ve done anything at all. It’s a survey of skullduggery by corporate media. It’s an introduction to numerous journalists far superior to the norm. And it’s an introduction to IF Stone (click here). It includes footage of a presentation of the annual Izzy Award which goes to journalists acting in Stone’s tradition.

One of the lies listed in the film and on the website is that of the Gulf of Tonkin (non-)Incident. Anyone paying attention knows of it now as a war lie. And it was a transparent war lie at the time in a particular sense. That is: had the North Vietnamese really shot back at a US ship off their coast, that would not have been any sort of legal, much less moral, justification for escalating a war. I’d love it if people could grasp that logic and apply it to the Black Sea, the Red Sea, and every other part of the earth today.

But the Gulf of Tonkin lies about Vietnamese aggression against the US ships innocently patrolling and firing off the coast of Vietnam were not transparent to people with faith in the US role of Global Policeman. Someone had to make the lies transparent. Someone had to document that in fact the Secretary of So-Called Defense and the President were lying. Sadly, nobody did that in the first 24 hours after the Congressional committee hearings, and that was all it took for Congress to hand the president a war.

And it was decades before White House transcripts came out and before the National Security Agency confessed, and additional years before former Secretary Robert McNamara did. Yet, those revelations simply confirmed what people paying attention knew. And they knew it because of IF Stone who just weeks after the (non-)incident published a four-page edition of his weekly newsletter exclusively about Tonkin.

Stone’s analysis is useful in looking at the incident or lack thereof this past month in the Red Sea off Yemen. And in fact it is to Yemen that Stone immediately turned on page 1 in 1964. The United Nations, including its US ambassador, had recently condemned British attacks on Yemen that Britain defended as retaliatory. President Dwight Eisenhower had also warned the French against retaliatory attacks on Tunisia. And President Lyndon Johnson, even at the time of Tonkin, Stone notes, was warning Greece and Turkey not to engage in retaliatory attacks on each other.

Stone, who tended to look even at written laws that nobody else paid any heed to, pointed out that three of them banned these sorts of attacks: the League of Nations Covenant, the Kellogg-Briand Pact, and the UN Charter. The latter two are still theoretically in place for the US government.

The United States in Vietnam, Stone goes on to show, could not have been innocently attacked but itself admitted to having already sunk a number of Vietnamese boats. And indeed the US ships, Stone reports, were in North Vietnamese waters and were there to assist South Vietnamese ships that were shelling two North Vietnamese islands. And, in fact, those ships had been supplied to South Vietnam by the US military and the good old American tax payers.

Stone did not have access to closed committee hearings, but he hardly needed it. He considered the assertions made in speeches by the only two senators who voted against the war. And then he looked for any rejoinders by the chairmen of the committees. He found their denials to be non-denials and nonsensical. It made no sense that the US ships simply happened to be randomly hanging around in the vicinity of the South Vietnamese ships. Stone didn’t believe it.

Stone also filled in the background information. The United States had been supporting guerrilla attacks on North Vietnam for years prior to the non-incident. And Stone raised numerous suspicions, including the question of why the US ships had supposedly made sure they were out in international waters for the (non-)incident to (not) occur, and the question of why in the world Vietnam would take on the United States military (something nobody could explain, though Eugene McCarthy proposed that perhaps they had been bored).

Missing from the film and website of All Governments Lie is IF Stone’s work on lies about the outbreak of the Korean War. We’ve learned more since he wrote it, but seen little more insightful, relevant, or timely work for our understanding of Korea and the world today.

Note: David Swanson wants you to declare peace at WorldBeyondWar.org. His new book is War No More: The Case for Abolition. The above article was posted at CounterPunch.

+ + + + +

SYRIAN GIRL MYSTERIOUSLY ‘SAVED’ AGAIN AND AGAIN

The West continues to use the mainstream media to sell their “story”. Here is a recent example that came to light in the current Syrian conflict.

At a glance, the photos, which went viral in the Arab and Western media on August 28, 2016, elicit pity and seemingly righteous indignation: for instance, a peaceful Lamb of God aka White Helmets’ volunteer carrying two injured children. The White Helmets - Syria Civil Defense - is a volunteer civil defense organization that operates in rebel-controlled Syria during the Syrian Civil War, which started in March 2011.

Social media say the photos were taken after the attack on the Al-Nayrab district of Aleppo. Pay attention to the injured girl: scared, dishevelled, with blood on her face. And she was “saved” more than once: the same girl is carried by the three (!) different “volunteers”. Russia-insider.com (click here) asks: Why was she carried by several men? The answer is simple: To make more tear-sqeezing photos for the Western media.

Armed “Saviours” Under “an-Nusra” Flags - Russian Spring investigation Of White Helmets’ Strange “Peacemaking” In Syria (click here)

The REAL Syria Civil Defence Exposes NATO’s ‘White Helmets’ as Terrorist-Linked Imposters (click here)

+ + + + +

Post a Comment